Best Bait Traps for American and German Cockroaches

“This post includes affiliate links for which I may make a small commission at no extra cost to you should you make a purchase.”

American and German cockroaches are some of the most common cockroach species found in households throughout the United States. There are many species of cockroach, and not all of them can be handled the same way. Some cockroaches, German in particular, are resistant to traditional methods of baiting.

American cockroaches are also commonly known as palmetto bugs or water bugs. These roaches have wings, but they rarely fly. An American roach prefers to eat decaying organic material when possible, but is also attracted to sweets and starches. Cockroaches may be attracted by sugar, and they may feed on the backs of wallpaper and book bindings as well.

German cockroaches are commonly found in hotels, restaurants, and apartment houses. Roaches and their eggs tend to come into a home while clinging to a person’s clothes, luggage, or other belongings. In homes with large German roach populations, you can smell a foul odor in the air.

These are insects that prefer warmth, food, and moisture. To control a German cockroach population, you have to take serious sanitation measures. These insects can cause a serious health hazard if they’re found in restaurants. Just one egg capsule brought through a door can mean an infestation six months down the line.

If you’re dealing with a roach infestation, the first thing you should do is identify what type of roaches you’re dealing with. If there are multiple types infesting your space at once, then you’ll need traps equipped to handle multiple species. Oftentimes, traps that will entice American roaches won’t appeal to German roaches. Conversely, traps specifically engineered to bait German roaches might not appeal to any other insects.

Fortunately, we’ve put together a list of some recommendations for traps that can attract both German and American roaches. These traps can bring in a host of other insects as well, so they’re helpful for keeping your pest population down.

Best Bait Traps for American and German Cockroaches

Product nameVolume or DimensionsNumber in PackType of Trap
#1. Syngenta
Our Best Pick

Check Price
30 grams4Gel
#2. Maxforce

Check Price
30 grams4Gel
#3. Catchmaster

Check Price
6 x 9 inches72Glue

#1. Syngenta Advion Cockroach Gel Bait

Check Price

This cockroach gel bait can be used to control multiple kinds of cockroaches. It comes with four tubes of gel and one plunger. Each of the tubes contains thirty milligrams of the gel solution. The baits can target German, Australian, American, Asian, Oriental, brown-banded, brown, and smoky brown cockroaches. It’s rare to find gels that are formulated to target German cockroaches, as they are among the hardest cockroaches to kill.

The gel uses a non-repellent and strongly smelling active ingredient called indoxacarb. Cockroaches are attracted to it. When the cockroach consumes the ingredient, it is then converted into an insecticide inside the insect’s digestive system thanks to the insect’s enzymes. Since the gel is not an insecticide to start with, it’s safer to use around the home than most chemical insecticides.

The baits are labeled to be used both indoors and outdoors. You can use the gel in residential, commercial, and industrial areas. Since you can control nearly every cockroach species at once, you don’t have to worry about buying multiple different baits or dealing with complicated inventory.

The manufacturer recommends rotating this gel bait with other gel baits on a three-month basis. Otherwise, the cockroaches may adapt and cease to be vulnerable to the bait. This is particularly true for German cockroaches. Other effective gel baits from the manufacturer include the Advion Evolution and Optigard Gel Bait.


#2. Maxforce FC Select Roach Killer Bait Gel

Check Price

One box of this roach killer gel from Maxforce FC Select has four tubes, each of which comes with thirty grams of gel. The gel uses a 0.01 percent concentration of Fipronil as its active ingredient.

It’s important to note that Fipronil, while being one of the most powerful insecticides on the market, is also one of the most potentially dangerous to humans and pets. If a child or a pet ingests it, they could have severe neurological and digestive symptoms that could be potentially life-threatening.

As long as the baits are used correctly, though, people shouldn’t be exposed to the toxic insecticide. Because the ingredient isn’t airborne like in a spray, there’s not a hazard for individuals with respiratory issues like asthma.

In fact, this is one of the most versatile cockroach baits on the market. It’s labeled for use in and around residential areas, commercial areas, and warehousing. Specific places that the baits can be used include food processing plants, hospitals, supermarkets, nursing homes, hotels, motels, bakeries, apartment buildings, bottling facilities, laboratories, schools, sewers, buses, aircraft, trains, boats, houses, kennels, office buildings, stores, kitchens, pet shops, and zoos.

As you can see, there are multiple industries involved in animal handling and food service that can use these baits. You just need to follow the label’s instructions for usage and storage. The gel can kill and control cockroach infestations across multiple species.

The gel kills both on contact and when it’s ingested. It may be more effective than the other gel on the list. Since the active ingredient is already in insecticide form when the cockroach touches it, the insect simply has to contact it. No ingestion is necessary. When the contaminated roach returns to the nesting area, other cockroaches will also become infected with the gel and die. Cockroaches will even die if they eat the bodies of other cockroaches that have been killed by the gel.


#3. Catchmaster AA1170 Pest Trap

Check Price

This glue board is a pest trap that uses glue instead of gel. Unlike the other options on the list, the board can be used for mice problems as well, so it’s a good option for people in older houses or rural areas. The traps won’t work against rats, however. There are seventy-two glue traps in a pack.

The Catchmaster glue traps are non-poisonous and use a peanut butter fragrance to trap cockroaches, crickets, grain moths, fruit flies, mice, and some other insects. You can either lie the trap flat like a sheet of paper, or you can fold it into a box to protect the glue’s integrity against dust and falling objects. The traps can be used in offices, bars, restaurants, homes, and other commercial and residential spaces.

One of the biggest selling points of the glue board is that it doesn’t use pesticides, insecticides, or poisons. Instead, it uses a special adhesive glue that will stop pests immediately. Rather than becoming hardened and rubbery within three months, a Catchmaster trap can last for more than a year at full potency. It also isn’t toxic to pets or people, making it a good choice for those with little ones or little critters around.

Another thing that sets the traps apart from other glue boards is that no oils are used in the glue or construction. Oils can mix with the body chemistry of rodents and some insects, which allows for escape. Because the glue boards have such a low profile, they can be easily placed anywhere.

When you’re using these boards to kill roaches, the best thing you can do is add scented bait to draw them in. The peanut butter scent may attract some, but not necessarily the entire infestation. Ideal places to put the traps are in areas near the wall that aren’t easily accessible to children and pets that might get stuck to them.

If a child or a household pet gets stuck in the glue trap, don’t worry. The glue isn’t toxic. You can apply household vegetable oil to get the glue to release painlessly.


Final Thoughts

The Syngenta gel bait is a good choice if you’re looking for a type of gel that can control multiple kinds of cockroaches. With four tubes of 30 grams, you get enough gel to bait multiple traps.

The Maxforce gel is another type of gel that’s a good choice for killing multiple different species of cockroaches. You get just as much in a pack as with the Syngenta. It’s versatile gel that can be used in hospitals, supermarkets, food processing plants, warehousing, commercial establishments, and residential areas. If you want a gel that’s safe to use in areas that handle food, this is your best bet.

The Catchmaster glue boards are a great choice if you want an infestation control trap that uses glue instead of gel. The baits attract multiple types of cockroaches, crickets, moths, fruit flies, and mice. From there, they get trapped on the glue. Each Catchmaster glue trap can have effectiveness that lasts for up to a year. In addition, the glue traps are easy to dispose of, and they aren’t toxic to pets or people.

Leave a Comment